Are Black People Better Off in Obama’s America?


For a huge slice of America, the Obama bubble burst in record time.  The initial elation of having toppled the establishment and brought change with a young, sexy black president gave way to the anger of hangers-on when they realized that the new president was mortal, his agenda controversial and the economy he inherited abysmal.  A year later with an as-of-yet jobless recovery, a searingly controversial health care reform agenda in limbo and millions concerned about government spending, Obama’s support is at a record low.  White support dropped from 76% right after the election to a recent figure of 56%. Not so with African Americans.  A recently released Pew Research Center survey on race showed that, economy-be-damned, 95% of black people still have a favorable opinion of Obama and that they were more optimistic about their progress in the last two years than they have been for the last 25 years.

The “Obama Effect” is dramatic.  Despite the fact that, in terms of joblessness and economic suffering, African Americans have been far harder hit than the average American, almost double the percentage of black people (39%) in 2009 say that the “situation of black people in this country” has improved over the last five years, in stark contrast to 20% in 2007.  Also, 53% of black respondents felt that life in the future would be better for black people and only 10% felt it would be worse.  This is quite the jump from the 2007 numbers (44% thought it would be better, 21% thought it would be worse).

Things are looking better in the race relations department too.  Fifty-four percent of African Americans report that Obama’s election has forged progress in this area.  Only 7% disagree.  The perceived gap between black and white also seems to be narrowing as a majority of African Americans believe that the two racial groups have grown more similar in terms of cultural values and standard of living; 52% of black people feel that if blacks cannot get ahead in the US, it is their own fault, not something that can be blamed on racial discrimination.  This figure is not necessarily Obama-inspired but has been changing steadily from the mid-90s when the opposite view was held by most black people.

When it comes down to the economy and jobs, whereas white perceptions of the state of the economy have plummeted since the recession began, black opinions have generally held steady, as has their perception of the state of their personal finances.

Of course, not all black people are fans. African American Chicagoan Isaac Hayes is running for Congress and is attempting the near-impossible feat of stealing Illinois District 2 from Jesse Jackson Jr.  In a BBC interview, he says that Obama “brought inspiration, him and his family, to the White House. I am proud to have a black president – America is proud, but that’s not the issue. He’s brought change, but it’s not the right kind of change. He’s allowed the left to pull him off his campaign promise to work with both sides of the aisle. I don’t think he believes in American exceptionalism: he’s been on an apology tour round the world, and I don’t agree with that.”

Hayes’ point is as widely-held as it is predictable.  With the exception of a well-deserved win in the Jan. 19 special election to fill the Senate seat previously held by Ted Kennedy in Massachusetts, Republicans have been spectacularly reliable sourpusses since Obama’s election.  Why wouldn’t they be?  Their former leader was universally despised; their policies blamed for the near ruin of America’s economy and their power to achieve anything more than a red-faced Washington hissy fit, cartoonishly diminished.

So how do you react to record high levels of African American optimism?  I suppose reactionary bigots would claim that black people are delusional, their perception of reality and American misery skewed by having one of their own in the Oval Office.  If little has improved and much has worsened since Obama took office, why else would black people be content?

Another Chicagoan, Reverend Leon Finney, founded the Metropolitan Apostolic Church and now leads The Woodlawn Organization. He has known Obama since he worked as a community organizer in his 20s.  He says that because of their history, black people are patient. “We are very proud. We are elated. Maybe, somewhat underemployed and unemployed still, but we have a lot of hope. You have to remember more than any other ethnic group the African-American population has learned to live with hardship and survive the harshest of situations. ‘Last hired, first fired’ is nothing new for the African-American community. My sense is that we are used to the rigors and better able to adapt and less frightened (by the recession) than our brothers and sisters of different colors.”

Instant gratification is not something that can happen in today’s America, no matter how much it is craved. Historically, the plight of the disadvantaged, while dramatically unjust, has been more the norm in American society.  But maybe, just maybe, the tides could be turning. While those accustomed to luxury and a secure spot at the top of the economic totem poll may protest targeted taxes and an overhaul of healthcare, could it be that Obama’s legacy will mean enhanced quality of life for those in America who need it most?


Bjorn Karlman

10 thoughts on “Are Black People Better Off in Obama’s America?”

  1. Watching the news on MLK Jr. night, it was great to see a group of kids performing skits, dance and music with a message. It was their way of paying tribute to MLK Jr. These kids want to see a better future. However, aren’t we already in a post racial US? If not, then I am very confused. We elected a black president just over a year ago. I would suggest that the discussion about race is more of a habit at this point than anything else; we talk about it only because it’s been a discussion point for so long. Is it time to move on to other, more important topics? It’s time to transition our understanding? We should be thinking about choosing the best candidate for the job, regardless of their race. It’s interesting that you say that “52% of black people feel that if blacks cannot get ahead in the US, it is their own fault, not something that can be blamed on racial discrimination.” I agree that we need to understand the past, but it’s time to move forward and not be stuck worrying about the well-being of a different race (or for that matter…creed, color, religion, national origin, ancestry, sex, age or disability). It’s time to let the past be the past.

  2. Denton, I think you are absolutely right that we should be moving forward instead of being stuck in the past. Obama ran on a largely post-racial platform. However, remembering MLK and the injustices he died trying to erase is entirely appropriate. We cannot forget the blatant legislated racism that existed within living history, nor should we be so naive as to think that just because we have elected a black man and begun to correct the wrongs of the past, we now live in a post-racial society.

  3. Perhaps we need to return to the premise and ask, “Is Obama black?” I doubt he would identify himself so without challenging the parameters of the question.

  4. Like everything else, perception is reality. People will always give different answers when answering for themselves and answering for a particular community.

    When you ask American’s if they are racist or if they know racists, very few will answer ‘yes’. When you ask them if America is racist, everyone says ‘yes’.

    If you were to ask black people if they are any better off today than they were a year ago, most would probably say they are worse off (not any presidents fault really, these recessions always have and always will happen). When asked about the ‘black community’ they say they are better off.

    Part of the problem is how poll questions are phrased. Instead of polling peoples perceptions, they should focus more on the people themselves.

    So the answer the question, black people are not better off in any measurable way. They are better off in the sense that they shouldn’t be as paranoid about racism now that white America voted for a black president. Being less paranoid is always a good thing.

  5. Funny how that which is not measurable often results in the most measurable outcome in the end. The fact that hope, as intangible as it may seem, changed the outlook of a lot of African Americans will in turn change their quality of life if they live into it as the positive narrative that it is.

  6. I agree. I think hope/perspective (whatever a person wants to call it) effects the attitude and vibe you give off to others. Attitude counts for a lot in my opinion. Almost no one likes negativity, and almost everyone loves a good positive person. If people like you, doors will be opened, and if people don’t like you it is always going to be harder to get your way.

  7. Once he loses the House in November, I will probably like him a lot more. Haha. He can be like Clinton, adopt all the Republican policies and pretend like they were his ideas.

Comments are closed.